Yes. Ice for Player 1 Down Up Up. For you Down Down Up. My Ice got from 75 50 25 to 37 76 12, that would be Unknown Up Down.
Sooo. Starting with the values posted so far, it seems the needed stats are distributed two lower or higher than 50 and not all of them in the same direction. But would this help? 75 to 37 means, it is lower than 75, but could still be higher than 50.
But, combining with my suspicion, that the total sum of all three stats will stay below 200 and above 150, I will guess that my Ice went actually Up Up Down. Unless they totally randomized the three stats and a starting point of 50 should work best in most cases.