Thread: How do you get girl drops from NPC harem battles?

The only time I've ever gotten drops during boss battles is when the judge matched my character type, Charm to be exact. Also, I've noticed that the judge I need seems to appear less often than the other two, Hardcore and Know-How. Say what you want, but for the first two days of the current Halloween event, I got no drops and the only judges I had were Hardcore and Know-How. Maybe the Charm judge actually activated while I was asleep, but the third day the Charm judge activated for me and I got the first girl from Gruntt in several tries, then switched to Dark Lord and got his girl in just 2 tries. This seems to work for event girls fairly quickly, but still takes a super long time now for regular boss girls. The last boss girl I got to drop, Sylvia, took about the same length of time, over 2 weeks. The one before that, The housemaid, took over 3 weeks.

I'd suggest only trying for girl drops when the judge is active that matches your affinity. Otherwise, just farm the boss that has the highest money drop until your judge activates. You're probably wasting time doing it any other way.

I thought it would be common sense to make event girls easier to drop than normal girls, since they are time limited...



Guess I won't get the 2nd event girl as usual, yet the normal girls are literally insta-given -_-

I have been beating on Edwarda for a week & haven't gotten a single girl drop yet. Getting very frustrating

Originally Posted by Unregistered

I'd suggest only trying for girl drops when the judge is active that matches your affinity. Otherwise, just farm the boss that has the highest money drop until your judge activates. You're probably wasting time doing it any other way.

Don't follow this guys advice, it's not correct. There is no easy way to get the drops.

Originally Posted by soviras

Don't follow this guys advice, it's not correct. There is no easy way to get the drops.

Never said it was easy. Just said that the only time I have EVER gotten drops is when the judge is active that matched my characters affinity. I'm not the first person to have noticed this or posted this on this forum.

During this event, I got nothing for almost the first 2 days. The very instant my judge activated, I got both even girls within one full recharge. That IS NOT a coincidence. I've been playing for almost 6 months and have NEVER gotten a girl to drop when the Hardcore or Know-how judge was active.

But whatever... everyone should play as they want.

Originally Posted by Unregistered

Never said it was easy. Just said that the only time I have EVER gotten drops is when the judge is active that matched my characters affinity. I'm not the first person to have noticed this or posted this on this forum.

During this event, I got nothing for almost the first 2 days. The very instant my judge activated, I got both even girls within one full recharge. That IS NOT a coincidence. I've been playing for almost 6 months and have NEVER gotten a girl to drop when the Hardcore or Know-how judge was active.

But whatever... everyone should play as they want.

It IS a coincidence, that's what random chance is going to result in for some people. You have confirmation bias because you observed something, but that is not a guarantee that you are correct. There are many more people who got girls on every judge, so we can dismiss the "you should only do it with the right judge" thing as the nonsense it is. People like you, who spread this nonsense, are only going to cause harm by making people think they should skip fights when the judges aren't for their specialty and thus having them miss out on the event girls because they only had a fraction of the chance they could have had.

The girl drop chances are fully random, there is no outside factor that improves your chances (not the judges, not the girls you choose, and not whatever other things you might think helps). Everything you observed is a coincidence due to the nature of randomness. Every pattern that people have claimed to observe has been disproved multiple times, including the judges. The only thing that improves your odds is the failed attempt bonus that was added recently, and that doesn't even apply to event girls.

You are also right, everyone should play as they want, but spreading misinformation that causes harm is "not playing how you want", that's sabotaging others.

Well since I started trying to drop the Girl from The Dark Lord & Gruntt.
The only judge I have seen so far has been Dame Charmante Currently she is looking to reset every 6 hours.
And every time i come in to see if there have been any other judges besides her there has not been any.
So I keep plugging away at trying to get the Orc girl from Dark Lord, but have not had a chance. i don't know if this is a
bug or whatnot but for the past several days now this judge has not been replaced

Any info or speculation? Please share.

Originally Posted by soviras

It IS a coincidence, that's what random chance is going to result in for some people. You have confirmation bias because you observed something, but that is not a guarantee that you are correct. There are many more people who got girls on every judge, so we can dismiss the "you should only do it with the right judge" thing as the nonsense it is. People like you, who spread this nonsense, are only going to cause harm by making people think they should skip fights when the judges aren't for their specialty and thus having them miss out on the event girls because they only had a fraction of the chance they could have had.

The girl drop chances are fully random, there is no outside factor that improves your chances (not the judges, not the girls you choose, and not whatever other things you might think helps). Everything you observed is a coincidence due to the nature of randomness. Every pattern that people have claimed to observe has been disproved multiple times, including the judges. The only thing that improves your odds is the failed attempt bonus that was added recently, and that doesn't even apply to event girls.

You are also right, everyone should play as they want, but spreading misinformation that causes harm is "not playing how you want", that's sabotaging others.

I'm not spreading false information, just sharing my actual experience with the game, and my conclusions associated with said experience. Something that happens once or twice, or even three times can be disregarded as coincidence, but when it happens over twenty times, it stops being a coincidence and starts to indicate a developing pattern. But rest assured, if I ever get a drop to another judge, then I will be the first to post that my theory was wrong. But until that time comes, the game is proving otherwise.

There is even a youtube video, from an older version of the game, but the guy is trying for Festival Bonnie. He tries 45 times and finally gets her to drop. But if you pay close attention to the judge that drops the girl, it's the Know-how judge that matches his type. He starts off with the Charm and then moves on to Hardcore judge with no luck. Then the when the know-how judge is active that matches his type, the girl drops. It's just one example, but there probably aren't many people who thought it important enough to video their Harem Heroes experience to share with the world.

htt ps://ww w.youtube.co m/watch?v=I7z7sNAM2Vs

(delete the spaces in the link)

Besides, no one is harmed by anyone sharing information and their opinions. If you feel that way, you're taking a stupid game WAY too seriously.

Originally Posted by Unregistered

I'm not spreading false information, just sharing my actual experience with the game, and my conclusions associated with said experience. Something that happens once or twice, or even three times can be disregarded as coincidence, but when it happens over twenty times, it stops being a coincidence and starts to indicate a developing pattern. But rest assured, if I ever get a drop to another judge, then I will be the first to post that my theory was wrong. But until that time comes, the game is proving otherwise.

There is even a youtube video, from an older version of the game, but the guy is trying for Festival Bonnie. He tries 45 times and finally gets her to drop. But if you pay close attention to the judge that drops the girl, it's the Know-how judge that matches his type. He starts off with the Charm and then moves on to Hardcore judge with no luck. Then the when the know-how judge is active that matches his type, the girl drops. It's just one example, but there probably aren't many people who thought it important enough to video their Harem Heroes experience to share with the world.

htt ps://ww w.youtube.co m/watch?v=I7z7sNAM2Vs

(delete the spaces in the link)

Besides, no one is harmed by anyone sharing information and their opinions. If you feel that way, you're taking a stupid game WAY too seriously.

If you spread misinformation that has been proven to be wrong already, that has a chance of causing people to make the mistake of believing it and doing something that lowers their chances. That is you harming their chances and with that their gameplay experience, even if not on purpose.

There are only a few people who claimed that the judges mattered, while there are dozens of people who have gotten drops with all three judges and with screenshots to prove it. Coincidence is a thing with RNG, spreading false information is exactly what you are doing. You keep insisting it's not a coincidence, but it is nothing but a coincidence. You haven't provided any proof for your claims that would hold up against the many screenshots that have been posted in the past and that are still being posted on a daily basis.

While twenty or more times is unlikely and I honestly don't believe you on your word for it (I don't think you actually paid attention to the judges until recently and just saw 2 or 3), it's not even the weirdest or most unlikely thing that ever happened. Anyone looking on the discords screenshot channel would see that most girls dropped on judges that aren't the same as the players specialty (64% during 4 months before the rebalance, similar after so far), and that the drops per judge were more or less equal.

Well, there are 3 judges, so there is 33% chance to have a drop happen on the judge corresponding to your type.

0.33 chance multiplied by itself 20 times gives 2.345734188103679287078463273601e-10, we can now multiply that by 100 to get % value back, which gives us 2.345734188103679287078463273601e-8% (duh lol). We can write it down as less science'y 0.000000023457341881%, or 2.3457341881 times in 100 million.

That is a chance to get a drop from your type of judge 20 times in a row, which assumes of course that there is really no judge to drop chance correlation (aka that there is the same % chance to get a drop at what ever judge is up at the drop moment), and it also counts only actual drops thus ignores failed attempts/fights.

This means that Unregistered dude is so damn lucky he/she should play some real money lottery, or like soviras said is lying/heavily exaggerating.

I personally don't pay much attention to anything while fighting trolls, but I am 99.9% sure I got drops when all 3 judges were up not just Hardcore one.