Quote Originally Posted by soviras View Post
It IS a coincidence, that's what random chance is going to result in for some people. You have confirmation bias because you observed something, but that is not a guarantee that you are correct. There are many more people who got girls on every judge, so we can dismiss the "you should only do it with the right judge" thing as the nonsense it is. People like you, who spread this nonsense, are only going to cause harm by making people think they should skip fights when the judges aren't for their specialty and thus having them miss out on the event girls because they only had a fraction of the chance they could have had.

The girl drop chances are fully random, there is no outside factor that improves your chances (not the judges, not the girls you choose, and not whatever other things you might think helps). Everything you observed is a coincidence due to the nature of randomness. Every pattern that people have claimed to observe has been disproved multiple times, including the judges. The only thing that improves your odds is the failed attempt bonus that was added recently, and that doesn't even apply to event girls.

You are also right, everyone should play as they want, but spreading misinformation that causes harm is "not playing how you want", that's sabotaging others.
I'm not spreading false information, just sharing my actual experience with the game, and my conclusions associated with said experience. Something that happens once or twice, or even three times can be disregarded as coincidence, but when it happens over twenty times, it stops being a coincidence and starts to indicate a developing pattern. But rest assured, if I ever get a drop to another judge, then I will be the first to post that my theory was wrong. But until that time comes, the game is proving otherwise.

There is even a youtube video, from an older version of the game, but the guy is trying for Festival Bonnie. He tries 45 times and finally gets her to drop. But if you pay close attention to the judge that drops the girl, it's the Know-how judge that matches his type. He starts off with the Charm and then moves on to Hardcore judge with no luck. Then the when the know-how judge is active that matches his type, the girl drops. It's just one example, but there probably aren't many people who thought it important enough to video their Harem Heroes experience to share with the world.

htt ps://ww w.youtube.co m/watch?v=I7z7sNAM2Vs

(delete the spaces in the link)

Besides, no one is harmed by anyone sharing information and their opinions. If you feel that way, you're taking a stupid game WAY too seriously.