Hmm, I really should set up two different team loadouts for each element, but then stuff like the Tower happens and I want the free space for teams to do that.
For general purpose I think I'll probably go with Herc with Trial by Jury for the time being, then. I doubt I'll use my Fires in Guild Orders much...my Light team is working moderately against the Light one now that I'm getting the hang of it, so I assume they'll be okay for other elements too.
I haven't gotten a single Phantom weapon yet, so I probably shouldn't be thinking that far ahead.
My Darks lack Atk Down so I was using Trial by Jury with Shingen so far. Do you think Shingen works for Dark? I've got Osiris with a small party-wide burst increase, and both Chernobog and Satan Awakened have combo-boosting skills. If that's not enough then I'll just switch to Herc and start buying her axes with the regalia I've saved up. I can buy two Dark soul weapons right now.
I do have the union Dark axe. One copy is broken to three stars, and I have two extra copies as well. I've also got this Dark hammer from union battles too, but only at two stars. Will there be another one where I can get more? And while I'm at it, will there be more events where I can get the Light union Staff? I have only one copy of that.