Quote Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
Si shingen weapon is better? I like the PF buff skill, but it’s an hp weapon.
For Shinge, there isn't a correct answer to that. They serve a different purpose.

The offensive weapon increases your general damage output by quite a lot (ESPECIALLY if you don't own a P2W Eidolon and/or run that team off-element). Also, allows Shingen to use PF without any outside help, which is incredibly valuable.

The defensive weapon gives you more HP which is always nice to have, but offers less general attack output - while increasing your burst output. This can be invaluable in content where stuff is a joke until the boss. However, Shingen will need help with PF, as she cannot reliably pull it off by herself.

In general, if you own a P2W Eidolon yourself for that element AND have help for Shingen, then the HP weapon is an option. If either of those is a no, then I'd recommend sticking to the offensive weapons. 30% elemental attack is just extremely good to have.