Hmm, formatting's going to suck, but here's the comparison between DMM's results and Nutaku's for SSR (I haven't looked/copied SR or R). Of course, there main difference right off the bat is that DMM's poll was taken after Neftis/Marduk/Mars/Shamash.
I'll list DMM's first then Nutaku's. DMM's results were listed by raw # of votes instead of %, so I summed it up and used that to get a percentage.
01. Sol - 13.03% ---------- Sol - 12.00%
02. Osiris - 8.42% --------- Satan - 9.40%
03. Satan - 6.90% -------- Gaia - 7.20%
04. Shamash - 5.60% ----- Osiris - 7.20%
05. Amaterasu - 5.42% ---- Amaterasu - 6.00%
06. Neftis - 5.35% -------- Daji - 5.60%
07. Gaia - 4.95% --------- Michael - 5.30%
08. Svarog - 4.18% ------- Ares - 5.30%
09. Ryu-Oh - 4.13% ------- Cthulhu - 5.10%
10. Uriel - 3.88% --------- Susanoo - 4.80%
11. Michael - 2.89% ------ Cao Cao - 4.60%
12. Aphrodite - 2.50% ---- Ryu-Oh - 3.10%
13. Shiva - 2.33% -------- Eros - 2.30%
14. Mars - 2.00% --------- Svarog - 2.20%
15. Cu Chulainn - 1.83% --- Aphrodite - 1.70%
16. Thor - 1.81% --------- Thor - 1.60%
17. Metatron - 1.72% ----- Titania - 1.50%
18. Poseidon - 1.57% ----- Metatron - 1.50%
19. Daji - 1.54% ---------- Hades - 1.40%
20. Azazel - 1.46% ------- Acala - 1.30%
21. Tyr - 1.45% ---------- Cu Chulainn - 1.30%
22. Cao Cao - 1.43% ----- Tyr - 1.30%
23. Susanoo - 1.43% ----- Shiva - 1.30%
24. Hastur - 1.25% ------- Uriel - 1.20%
25. Hades - 1.24% ------- Raiko - 1.00%
26. Cthulhu - 1.24% ------ Hastur - 1.00%
27. Raphael - 1.20% ------ Raphael - 0.80%
28. Jupiter - 1.09% ------- Poseidon - 0.80%
29. Eros - 1.05% --------- Azazel - 0.70%
30. Odin - 1.01% --------- Odin - 0.60%
31. Titania - 0.95% ------- Jupiter - 0.60%
32. Sarasvati - 0.84% ---- Brahma - 0.60%
33. Ares - 0.76% --------- Ea - 0.60%
34. Acala - 0.65% -------- Sarasvati - 0.50%
35. Brahma - 0.64% ------ Yama - 0.40%
36. Raiko - 0.59%
37. Yama - 0.59%
38. Ea - 0.57%
39. Marduk - 0.52%