lots of replies... but here goes

also, link edited cause i'm allowing others to edit this as well if they wish

Quote Originally Posted by WhatIconceal View Post
IMO needs a lot of work:

-text formats, headings, right now it's kinda wall of text;
-more general info regarding effects like character attack vs elemental attack (when one is better than another and why), main/sub eidos and summon/passive effect, friends/non-friends eidos, mention that non-friends eidos passive actually works etc.;
-maybe some eidos orb shop info;
-you already started this but make the division more distinct - rarity (R-SR-SSR)/how to get (gem or jewels/prem gacha/events/story quest drops/materials exchange shop) /passive effects (like 30% chara atk/ability DMG, 30% chara/30% burst-streak DMG, 40% chara/20% HP etc.);
my suggestion is smth like this: first goes rarity, then how to get - basically just 2 options (f2p and permium), maybe add detailed for each eido later, then group them by passive effects; after that list element, atk/hp stats, summon effect and do a basic analysis like 'meh passive, good summon, nice stats, useful as sub eido';
-probably the most important - TERMS, just a few examples:



it's all over the place; the "attack power" you use is confusing as hell, you have to use either "character attack" or "elemental attack";

Jack Frost part:


maybe it's just me but when i read that i thought about DoT (damage over time) and not about overdrive charge orbs;

-small addition to formatting/grouping eidos part and why i thinks that's important - to avoid stuff like this:



literally just all the way thru the SSR part. Maybe that's the way guides need to be idk, but personally i'm not a fan of this stuff. I prefer things to be short and on-point.
personally, not sure how to format this in a way others would like. some enjoy reading this way, and others don't. i've already learned that in a guide i did for a game called Elsword...

but the wording being everywhere can be an issue. probably need a list of common terms posted at the start then stick to that throughout the enitre thing

Quote Originally Posted by QXZ View Post
i would suggest

1. adding a section to rate or rank the eidos

2. give examples of a good eido lineup.
yeah, this is still a work in progress. honestly, i'd like others input on this as well so i'm willing to open up editing so i'm not the only one doing so

definitely need a rating system too.. probably on the scale of 1-100 depending on the eidolons... but if all of them int he game aren't listed, then i can't see less ratings than 10 happening cause the best R eidolons would likely hit that range

Quote Originally Posted by sanahtlig View Post
This is way too long given the limited scope of the topic and its relative simplicity. Eidolons come in a few basic categories, and after that the only difference between them is the summon effect and the element. The summon effect is generally a very minor consideration, except for Behemoth.


This is pretty misleading. SSR eidolons other than the +100% eidolons are nearly worthless in the long-run without multiple LBs. Since what to start with is probably the single most important decision most players will make, there's no room for confusion. If in doubt, just link my rerolling guide. I can update with an explanation of why the +100% eidolons are optimal starting picks if needed.
while 100% eidolons are the best one to get, if someone rerolls for specific kami instead, they may not end up with the 100% eidolons as well

remember, this is a guide more suited to what a player may currently have, not what's best to get (even though it is pointed out how valued something typically is). most players probably won't have the patience to get multiple kami and the 100% eido to match. it's like rerolling until you get amaterasu, svarog, mars, and belial all in one roll...

whether the player values key kami over the 100% eidolons in rerolling is up to them (i'd suggest getting at least one key kami and the 100% eido to match), but this is more to point out "hey, there's this OP eidolon you could have" while also saying "this is what you can be using until you get something better"