Originally Posted by
Cobblemaniac
For your case however, since you don't have the B frame you need, I'd advise dropping Shingen in favor of Joan simply because you aren't gonna see that much of a difference single bursting every few turns compared to just playing it safe. Shingen's setup only works well in a team which can keep up with her burst gen (therefore wind meta) for the reason that if you're not buffing burst damage or nuke damage itself to absurd levels, you're bursting fast enough to absurd levels to keep up, and water has none of that. Future water himes aren't burst gen heavy as well, so my bias also leans to Hercules in that regard, but the B frame wall is a bit bothersome in your case.
At least currently, my advice for new players is to basically get Asherah if they don't want to face endurance torture. Otherwise, it's better to drop water as an element altogether, the other elements are much better suited for dealing with endgame meta.