Thread: HBC's FKG 6* Tier List

Originally Posted by Wutan

It's hard

No its not

Fuck that tsundere wannabe. C+ is good enough for her.

Also twilight is right in that factoring in the "waifu-ism" (so no S tier Red Ginger I am sorry lads) messes up the overall relatively unbiased evaluation.

Thus if its a Waifu for the person, you should always do split score. If its not a waifu thus your review is not skewed towards higher tier because of personal likes you dont need to include it.
Power/Balance Score: X
Waifu Score: S++++++ because Helenium, and and because Mei and and because Victoria, a-and Aizoon of course !!! And, and,and..... you get what I mean

And yea, this is still mostly for the fun. If we for some miraculous reason get an influx of new DMM FKG players, they can refer to this and the Tactica thread, since we do all the "research" in here, thus its a lot of valuable info accessible by anyone, anytime all the time, but ultimately it is mainly for fun so in short > Dont sweat it *thumbsup*

Best case scenario would be if we had a whale like Allocer here of course.

A guy who has all Rainbows maxed out and available. Comparisons would be so much easier

About Waifu traits in this thread:

Well i wrote in the rules all voters should eliminate as much bias as possible.

Either if they like the girl, are indifferent to or dislike the girl.

I accept eliminating all bias is impossible cause it's human. Therefore i won't forbid others to write about waifuism if they want to. As long as it won't become repetetive where someone says in every other vote:

"Rhubarb Barbara is the best Waifu cause she makes the best Rhubarb Cakes south of the Mississippi " i don't have much of a problem with it (Waifuism shouldn't influence the overall voting to much of course).

I just hope all votes are reasonable and fair

Personally i won't speak about any waifu qualities here cause my posts are quite long and i try to seperate as much as possible between Unit and Girl.

Originally Posted by Wutan

Personally i won't speak about any waifu qualities here cause my posts are quite long and i try to seperate as much as possible between Unit and Girl.

Hearing those cold words from the one she loved the most, her head lowered ever so slightly. While still trying to keep up a brave front, she felt a little sting of pain in her chest. Turning her face to escape his sight...
Mapple cried...
just a little...
inside her heart

.
Bad Wutan mofu >:3 making waifus cry fufu ! >:3

Didn't you know,bud?

Maple likes Cold Hearted Assholes What is the term for a male Tsundere???

Just kidding of course

I could make a seperate Waifu Appreciation Thread to praise her awesomeness.

But Maple should already know how much i love her considering she got a lot of competition in form of Corn Cockle, Foxy (Miko) and Habranthus. She is still my number 1.

Heck you made an awesome Signature for me. I could have choose every other Girl. That alone shows how much i like her ;D

But enough of this...Back to serious Voting Business

Voting score can be differ from 2 reasons as I see in the forum here.

1. Waifuism and thus biased. It's unavoidable but at least don't make it super obvious.
2. You have/don't have the girl. When you have the girl and use her all the time in various build up you can see potential or weakness much clearer than one who doesn't have her. That's why I always mark 'paper only' to indicate that my rambling come from text and data only. Never use the girl myself or at least rarely use via helper team. I also separate extra section as I note, a more subjective view that could do or have nothing to do with waifu factor. Just whatever things that first come to mind when talking about her.

Whatever it is, just chill and go with what you think. Grading like this can plus or minus one without problem. It's not like someone just barge in and said 'Kerria suck and deserve rank D/E because I said so' If the dissonance become severe like that, then we can talk later.

PS: Finally decided to give Cattleya a B It's somewhere around C+ and B- but since I don't have her I will give her credit by rounding up rather than down.

From now on I'll use your "paper only" mark as well in the future if you don't mind ;D

I wish Helper Squads would have more meaning in late game. They are really helpfull if you are a new player or for Whaleships. But that's about it.

Sadly you can't bring Helper Squads to the hardest maps cause often times they are just forbidden there.

Also on normal story maps or Event maps we can't test the real strength of someones Helper Squad (or a specific Rainbow) cause the pests are way to weak there...

Just to be clear, that is why I brought it up in my initial post and after seeing what Wutan responded with, I agreed to keep the 2 values as separate as possible. So I do still stand by my S- vote of Red Ginger as you can see that I based my judgment off my experience with her and her stats/abilities. In the end, I admitted myself that I was strongly leaning on the "A" tier side but was just slightly convinced enough that she was "S-", in an unbiased analysis with no waifu influences. Then of course I naturally went on to gush over her on my waifu feelings. Same with Cactus, I gave a strictly unbiased analysis before waifu judging. So I have been doing my best to respect Wutan's rules and have fun with it. If others feel differently, I am sorry you feel that way. So I'll keep going forward being as honest and unbiased as possible with my official scoring before a separate fanboying vote that Wutan already knows doesn't count for anything.