Quote Originally Posted by Unregistered View Post
After leeching 2 fragments per raid for around 3 weeks I finally have enough Regalia to get one Soul Weapon. Running Andromeda and well on the path to getting D'art, should I get D'art's gun, Shingen's spear (have Yukimura from UE HSP but not Shingen yet), or Hercules' axe (still ages away from unlocking her)?
Given the rate you're getting fragments, I would save it until you unlock Hercules. If you've hit a wall and just need more dmg, get the elemental atk weapon for the soul you use most frequently. There are some exceptions, like Andromeda is ok for raids if you want to keep others alive (for that, her hp weapon is better, but it's not great outside of raids and frankly, it's kinda a thankless role.) D'Art's SS is useful for Ex skill but she's not a great soul to run generally, unless you're severely lacking in debuffs, in which case her hp weapon can be helpful. Hercules' axe will help a lot with debuff problems as well though and is just a much better long term investment.

You may want to consult Slashley's which soul to use thread. Also, if you want more than just the generic advice given, you can post your team setup and what element(s) you main and what content you're struggling with.

Btw, Yukimura doesn't benefit from Shingen's spear, so there's no point getting it right now. If you just unlocked Yukimura, you're still many months away from Shingen.