Either that or a rich man's Elaine. She is a nice low investment unit for newbies since she doesn't take fancy fodder and out damages witches, so at least in the short term she has her uses. Unfortunately, having a tanking skill backed up by a jack-of-all-trades stat line isn't a great deal on a low tier units. "Pretty close" is OK for horse shoes and hand grenades but for tanking? Not so much. Generally speaking, the lower the tier, the more narrowly focused you want the unit to be so it has a better chance of at least filling its niche. Being an all-rounder is a much better deal when you're a black tier like Sybilla and are given an extra scoop of stats just for waking up in the morning.