You mean four 4★?
My first 10+1 was this one:
Only 2 4★ (1 new).
My second was even more frustrating:
1 5★ I already had (knowing I have only 2 5★ from the 2 100% 5★ Gatchas).
(I thought I had already spend 150 FG to try 3 10+1... maybe I didn't take a screenshot, or I didn't tr more than twice, don't remember... )