Well...gave it a second shot, and bought the 5 gatcha pack (7 tickets total).
1st roll, new rare.
2nd roll, old SR and rares.
3rd roll...PIRATE LADY! The only event SR I was missing, and the only card I actually wanted!

Now I'm just missing Fusayo, and not sure if I should use the last 2 rolls I have on her. Oh yeah, revival gatcha still sucks