Here is what I used and what I got:

2 Rare Tickets + 1 Pero Pudding:

Attempt 1: 1 Wild Card 5 + 1 Pero Pudding = Slim Silver Acorn Time: 1 hour 30 min
Attempt 2: 1 Wild Card 5 + 1 Peronamin = Slim Silver Acorn Time: 1 hour 30 min
Attempt 3: 20 candy + 1 rare ticket = Slim Silver Acorn Time: 1 hour 30 min
Attempt 4: Normal Card Aoe Sugai = Fat Silver Acorn Time: 2 hour 30 min


Pero Pudding x 3

Attempt 1: 1 Wild Card 5 + 1 Pero Pudding = Slim Silver Acorn Time: 1 hour 30 min



A few things I've noticed, and I'm sure others have noticed as well:

1. The 'confirm' button changes after you set the items. It goes from bronze, to silver, to gold, depending on the items and the # added. At the very least you will know if you are going to get silver or gold, etc.

2. The wait time for the limited cards, and probably 'high level' items will be longer even if you use the same 'ingredients'. At least that is how it was with me.

3. Rare tickets and puddings are probably the best items to give up if you are going for the cards. Just gotta cross your fingers and hope for the best. So, good luck everyone. ♥